A sunny citrus garden and teak lounge chairs beside the shaded terrace of a warm ivory Arcadia ranch home.

How the Rest of Arcadia Priced During Its Record Year

  • November 19, 2026

In January, a French-inspired estate at 6415 E. Exeter Blvd. came to market at $18.5 million. According to KTAR's report, published with the Phoenix Business Journal, five parties showed interest, and the first offer opened at $14 million. The bidding went up from there, and in April the 8,434-square-foot house closed for $17.1 million in cash. The outlet called that a record for Arcadia.

That sale set the year's headline, and the headlines have kept climbing. Buyers looking at Arcadia this winter will meet those numbers in conversation long before they meet them in a contract. Below the estate tier, the ZIP code data tells a different story from the record.

A Record Set Below Its Asking Price

There are two numbers in the Exeter sale, and both matter. The first is $2,027.51 per square foot, which KTAR reported as the price the estate reached. The listing agent told the outlet that other estates selling near $2,000 a square foot sit on two to five acres, while this house is on nearly one acre. In other words, Arcadia land was priced in April like acreage on much larger estates.

The second number is the ratio. The house listed at $18.5 million and closed at $17.1 million, which is about 92 percent of its original ask. That held true even with five interested parties and a bidding war. Even the strongest sale of the year closed below its first asking price. The record shows how much a buyer was willing to pay. It does not show how much a seller could ask.

The address on the report is also worth a look. KTAR lists the property as Scottsdale, not Phoenix. Arcadia's name crosses the city line, so a neighborhood record and a ZIP code report do not always measure the same homes.

The Asks That Followed

The Exeter sale did not end the conversation. The Phoenix Business Journal reported in April that the listing agent planned to bring three spec homes under construction on Exeter Boulevard to market at more than $20 million each. That was a plan for future listings, made the same month a $17.1 million sale was called a record.

In September, a second marker appeared a short drive away. KTAR reported that the founders of Two Hawks Design + Build had put the custom estate they built for their own family at 5626 E. Montecito Ave. on the market as a private sale for $23.5 million. The home has 9,388 square feet, six bedrooms and six and a half baths, and was developed and built under the direction of principal Arash Hoss. Arizona Foothills Magazine's October 26 feature names architect C.P. Drewett and landscape architect Berghoff Design Group as collaborators. It also traces the design to places the family visited, including Amangiri in southern Utah and San Miguel de Allende, with openings placed to frame views of Camelback.

At that asking price, the Montecito estate works out to roughly $2,500 a square foot. KTAR noted it could set a neighborhood record if it sells near that number. That would be about 23 percent above the Exeter record on a per-foot basis. As of the October feature, the estate was listed as available.

New construction is setting the upper limit for Arcadia's price expectations. That matters at every price point, because new asks are compared against the most recent record.

Why the 85018 Median Jumped in October

The ZIP code data is where the record sales start to look different. The Phoenix REALTORS Local Market Update for 85018, current as of November 3, 2026, shows a single-family median sale price of $2,113,500 for October 2026. That is up 30.5 percent from $1,620,000 in October 2025.

The other rows in the same report explain most of that gain. Closed sales in October 2026 rose to 49 from 27 a year earlier. The average sale price rose 39.4 percent to $2,488,300, faster than the median. When the average climbs faster than the median and the number of closings nearly doubles, more expensive homes are making up a bigger share of sales. That is mostly a change in what sold, not a 30 percent rise in the value of a typical house.

The year-to-date figures are steadier. Through October 2026, the 85018 single-family median was $1,725,000, up 16.9 percent from $1,475,000 over the same period of 2025. Closed sales rose 23.2 percent, to 387 from 314. That is still a strong year. It also sits far below the Exeter and Montecito estates, because the ZIP covers far more than the estate streets. The City of Phoenix's Camelback East village profile describes much of the area's housing as built between 1950 and 1970. The Arcadia name also reaches well west of the original estate blocks. PHOENIX magazine has described Arcadia Lite as running from Camelback Road to Indian School Road between 32nd and 44th Streets.

Where Buyers Have Room Below the Record Tier

Buyers working in the $1.5 million to $4 million range should pay less attention to the headline median and more to the rows on negotiation and supply. Through October 2026, 85018 single-family sellers received 96.1 percent of list price on average, and the October figure alone was 95.9 percent. On a $2 million listing, a 4 percent gap is about $80,000. Homes took 79 days on average to sell year to date, up from 75 a year earlier. October ended with 199 single-family homes for sale, up 8.7 percent from 183, and 5.4 months of supply.

The most useful row for a buyer this winter is pending sales. Pending sales in October 2026 fell to 18 from 30 a year earlier, a 40 percent drop, even though year-to-date pendings were up 15.3 percent. Pending contracts become the next months' closings. One month is a small sample, and the report itself warns that small samples can make percent changes look extreme. Even so, fewer October contracts with more homes on the market means sellers listing into the holidays face more competition for fewer buyers.

The townhouse and condo side of 85018 shows the same pattern more sharply. In October 2026, the condo median eased 2.8 percent to $345,000, days on market reached 111, and supply stood at 7.7 months.

So the ZIP's numbers say two things at once. At the top, a small group of new and estate-scale homes is pushing toward per-foot levels Arcadia has never recorded. Across the rest of the ZIP, homes take longer than two months to sell, close about 4 percent under list, and face more competition from other listings than they did a year ago. A buyer who reads the first story and prices offers by it gives up the advantage the second story gives them.

How This Plays Into a Purchase Decision

The gap between new construction and older homes is also a choice about which kind of property to buy. A new build in Arcadia this year is priced against the Exeter and Montecito markers, by sellers who can point to a record. An original 1950s or 1960s ranch on a good lot is priced against the year-to-date ZIP figures, where sellers have accepted under list. Buyers weighing a finished house against one they would update or replace will find our piece on whether to rebuild or renovate a classic Arcadia ranch is the next step in that thinking.

Sellers can use the same data. An owner of a well-kept older home in 85018 who prices by the October median, or by per-foot figures from new construction on Exeter or Montecito, is pricing against a different product. The year-to-date ratio of 96.1 percent is the realistic benchmark for most listings this season. A home valuation based on comparable homes, not on the year's headlines, is where pricing should start.

Questions Buyers Are Asking About Arcadia This Winter

Did Arcadia home values rise 30 percent this year? The 30.5 percent figure is the October 2026 single-family median for ZIP 85018 compared with October 2025, and closings nearly doubled that month. The year-to-date median through October rose 16.9 percent. Both figures are affected by how many high-end homes closed.

Is the $23.5 million Montecito estate the new Arcadia price? It is an asking price on a private listing, reported in September and featured in October 2026. KTAR noted it could set a record if it sells near $2,500 a square foot. The highest closed sale in the April coverage remains $17.1 million on Exeter Boulevard.

Is winter a good time to make an offer in 85018? The October 2026 data showed 5.4 months of supply, sellers receiving 95.9 percent of list, and pending sales down 40 percent from a year earlier. Those conditions favor buyers with more than they did a year ago, especially below the new-construction tier.

Prices on Exeter Boulevard and Montecito Avenue will keep making news this season, and the best decisions in Arcadia will come from reading the data underneath them. ROCO Luxury Homes can review current 85018 sales with you, house by house, to separate what the estate tier is setting from what the rest of Arcadia is closing at. Book a Private Consultation, and visit our Arcadia neighborhood page or buyer services to start.

Let Us Connect You With Our Community

Intimate knowledge of the greater Phoenix area has resulted in tremendous professional success. Year after year we remain in the top 1% of realtors in Arizona based on sales volume.

Follow Us on Instagram